Speculators turn bearish, but bulls are even more confident rally will persist
(NEW YORK) Speculators are increasing their bearish bets against two-thirds of the 50 largest emerging-markets companies. That’s making the bulls even more confident stocks will keep rising from Brazil to China.
Short sales on Brazilian oil company Petroleo Brasileiro SA’s US-traded shares climbed in September to the highest since July 2006, data compiled by Bloomberg show. Wagers against Woori Finance Holdings, South Korea’s third-biggest financial services company, jumped to a four-year high. Options to sell China Mobile Ltd, the world’s largest wireless phone company by users, exceeded those to buy by the most since 2000.
Bears say the five-year rally that lifted the Morgan Stanley Capital International Emerging Markets Index more than 300 per cent to a record last week is over. They’ve got it wrong, say DWS Scudder, Credit Suisse Group and Fisher Investments Inc, which oversee US$1.7 trillion and expect faster economic growth to help developing nations avoid the stock tumbles of 1998 and 2000. Rather than causing declines, the bears will fuel gains by covering their positions, says DWS.
‘To me, it’s a more bullish sign,’ said Robert Froehlich, Chicago-based chairman of the investor strategy committee at DWS Scudder, which helps oversee US$333 billion as the US mutual fund unit of Frankfurt-based Deutsche Bank AG. ‘You’ve got a group of people that says, ‘Just because it’s gone up more than the rest of the market, just because it’s a high flyer, it means it has to go down.’ I don’t think that’s the way to make money.’
Developing markets are Mr Froehlich’s favourite pick and he expects their shares to gain as much as 8 per cent this quarter. His firm added to its stock positions in China, Taiwan, South Korea and Poland when the MSCI Emerging Markets Index fell 18 per cent in the 18 days ended Aug 16. The measure has since climbed 26 per cent to a record.
During the market’s rebound, short sales – where traders sell borrowed shares on expectations prices will fall – climbed for 36 American depositary receipts in the Bank of New York Emerging Markets 50 ADR Index in the month ended Sept 14, Bloomberg data showed. They fell or were unchanged for 14 stocks.
Among the 10 biggest companies, short interest increased for seven, including Rio de Janeiro-based Petrobras, Brazil’s state- owned oil company. Short sellers upped their bets against the ADRs to 13.6 million shares in mid-September, the highest since July last year and a jump of 8.4 per cent from a month earlier.
Buying insurance
Wagers against Seoul-based Woori Finance’s ADRs increased to 120,295 shares in mid-September, the highest since they were listed in 2003 and almost three times more than in mid-July.
In the options market, the ‘put-call ratio’ on China Mobile jumped to 2.07 times in September, the highest since the same month in 2000. Higher ratios indicate investors are buying more insurance against price declines. Puts give the right to sell a security for a certain amount, called the strike price, by a given date. Calls convey the right to buy.
The MSCI Emerging Markets Index plunged 54 per cent from its peak on Feb 10, 2000, after a global sell-off in technology stocks caused investors to abandon riskier assets. The measure has since climbed almost fivefold from its low on Sept 21, 2001, as growth in the US and China spurred demand for everything from mobile phones to oil and iron ore.
The MSCI Emerging Markets Index climbed 14 per cent in the third quarter, beating a 2 per cent gain in developed markets.
Developing nations posted nine of the 10 biggest advances last quarter, led by a 48 per cent surge in China’s CSI 300 Index. Bulgaria’s Sofix index rose 31 per cent after economic growth got a boost from the nation’s integration in January with the European Union. Turkey’s ISE National 100 Index added 15 per cent, helped by the re-election of Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan that gave him a mandate to proceed with EU membership talks.
Emerging-market stocks have become victims of their own success and are now too expensive relative to earnings, according to Fifth Third Asset Management’s Keith Wirtz.
The MSCI Emerging Markets Index is valued at 17.20 times companies’ profit, compared with a ratio of 16.34 for the MSCI World Index. That’s the biggest discount that developed nations have traded at versus emerging markets since February 2000, according to weekly data compiled by Bloomberg.
‘There seems to be better relative valuations in the developed world,’ said Mr Wirtz, who oversees US$22 billion as Fifth Third’s chief investment officer in Cincinnati. He’s been selling shares in China, the Philippines, and Malaysia and adding technology, industrial and energy stocks in the US and Japan.
Adrian Mowat, chief Asian and emerging-market strategist for New York-based JPMorgan Chase & Co, wrote in a note last week that developing nations’ stocks may be dragged down by a global slowdown and that investors are in ’state of denial’ about the threats to economic and profit growth.
Favourite regions
Credit Suisse’s Robert Weissenstein is more sanguine. He said companies in developing countries will profit the most because their economies are growing the fastest.
Developing countries are forecast to expand 8 per cent this year, compared with 2.6 per cent for advanced economies, according to the Washington-based International Monetary Fund. China, India and Russia will account for half of the world’s growth.
‘Favourite regions? I’d go with the emerging markets,’ said Mr Weissenstein, New York-based chief investment officer for private banking in the Americas at Credit Suisse, which oversees US$1.33 trillion. ‘They offer a tremendous value in terms of earnings growth. For three times the growth, you bet I’d pay more.’
China Mobile’s Hong Kong-listed shares have tripled in the last two years, making it the world’s fourth-largest company by market value. The Beijing-based company, whose 343.6 million customers outnumber the US population, said profit surged 29 per cent last quarter after adding a record number of users.
For Kenneth Fisher of Fisher Investments, the largest shareholder of China Mobile’s ADRs, that means the bears will ultimately capitulate and help fuel further gains.
‘They’re spitting into the wind,’ said Mr Fisher, who oversees about US$42 billion at Fisher Investments in Woodside, California. ‘It tends to make me more bullish.’
Source: Bloomberg (Business Times 3 Oct 07)