WHAT are we to make of it when spokesmen for the world’s most powerful economies and financial institutions begin to contradict each other in public – or make remarks which appear less than consistent with reality?
Today, the finance ministers and central bankers of the G-7 – namely the countries of the US, Britain, Canada, France, Germany, Italy and Japan – hold their semi-annual get-together in Washington, in the runup to this weekend’s International Monetary Fund and World Bank meetings.
Very public attempts to influence today’s agenda were already taking place early last week, with the leaders of France and Italy appearing to have become particularly vociferous this time. Grumbling that a too-strong euro hurts Europe’s growth and exports, they have tried to lead joint European demands for the US to reiterate its ’strong’ US dollar policy.
In short, the Europeans are getting annoyed that the euro has once again scaled fresh post-launch highs versus the US dollar over the past week, but the yen and yuan have not been contributing their fair share of upside adjustment in response to the fast-falling greenback.
They do have a point. Since the end of last year, the euro has risen some 17 per cent versus the US dollar, while the yuan has only strengthened 7 per cent, and the yen has actually weakened by 5 per cent. Yet, even within Europe, not all appear as flustered on this currency issue. North Europeans like the Germans and the Dutch, for example, have been far less vocal or upset, at least in public, on the subject.
To be sure, it does get a little surreal when the US is asked to reiterate a strong US dollar policy at a time when the US dollar is sliding across a broad front in the real world – and when economic logic suggests that more US dollar downside is needed to correct its record current account deficit with the rest of the world. Over the past fortnight, we have in fact seen the US currency slide to lows not seen in 10, 23 and 31 years versus currencies like the Singapore, Australian and Canadian dollars – on top of recording fresh post-launch lows versus the euro.
To calm jittery financial markets, US Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson has deemed it necessary to come out and help out the Europeans by reiterating – both last week and this – that a strong US dollar is indeed in his country’s interest.
Yet, even as he tried to carry that message across, the International Monetary Fund’s managing director Rodrigo Rato decided to warn this week that the US dollar is in fact still overvalued – despite trading at near record lows. And that it needs to fall even further.
The key message here is that all involved stand to lose out if the US dollar should suddenly collapse; there is a need to manage its fall. When you stop to think about it, isn’t that exactly what Asian countries like China have been trying to do in terms of the US dollar’s slide against their own currencies over the course of 2007?
Source: Business Times 19 Oct 07







