CEO steps down; bank’s sub-prime hit may reach US$11b
(NEW YORK) Citigroup Inc, the profit engine built by Sanford ‘Sandy’ Weill, has seized up.
The biggest US bank by assets said yesterday that sub-prime mortgages and related securities lost as much as US $11 billion of their value in the past month, a decline that may wipe out half of the company’s profit so far this year.
The New York-based company also said in a statement that Charles Prince, Mr Weill’s hand-picked successor, has stepped down. Former Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin will become chairman and Citigroup’s most senior executive in Europe, Win Bischoff, will be interim CEO.
Citigroup’s woes left international banks and stock markets reeling yesterday, feeding fears that more banks will have to confess to major losses. British banks Barclays and Royal Bank of Scotland saw their stock shed about 3.0 per cent in value. In Tokyo, Mitsubishi UFJ Financial, Sumitomo Financial and Mizuho Financial fell by a similar amount.
The Morgan Stanley Capital International Asia Pacific Index lost 1.9 per cent to 165.43 as of 5:33 pm in Tokyo, having on Nov 2 slipped 2.2 per cent from a record close. Financial shares were the biggest drag among the benchmark’s 10 industry groups yesterday.
Japan’s Nikkei 225 Stock Average slid 1.5 per cent to 16,268.92 while Hong Kong’s Hang Seng Index slumped 5 per cent. Most South-east Asian stock markets also extended losses on credit fears. The Straits Times Index fell 45.14 points to close at 3,670.18.
Citigroup said that credit-market upheaval in October impaired by as much as a fifth its US$55 billion book of subprime mortgages and related bonds. The writedown costs, which will be recorded in the fourth quarter if markets do not recover, add to the almost US$7 billion of costs for bad debt, bond and loan losses recorded in the third quarter.
The fourth-quarter charges may leave the company with a loss of 26 cents a share, Punk Ziegel & Co analyst Dick Bove wrote in a Nov 5 report. It would be Citigroup’s first quarterly loss since at least 1998.
Before the announcement, the company was expected to report US$5.32 billion of profit in the fourth quarter, the average estimate of six analysts surveyed by Bloomberg.
‘Significant uncertainty continues to prevail in financial markets,’ Citigroup said in the statement. The company said that its capital ratios ‘will return within the range of targeted levels by the end of the second quarter of 2008′, allowing it to maintain the current dividend, the company said.
Citigroup is participating in a US$80 billion fund being set up by banks to draw investors back into the market for short-term debt. The fund, also backed by Bank of America and JPMorgan, was announced last month with the encouragement of Treasury Secretary and former Goldman Sachs CEO Henry Paulson.
The performance of remaining sub-prime investments, which totalled US$55 billion as of Sept 30, is partly dependent on ‘the underlying performance of the economy’, chief financial officer Gary Crittenden said in an interview.
Analysts at CIBC World Markets and Morgan Stanley told clients last week to get rid of Citigroup shares. CIBC’s Meredith Whitney said that Citigroup may have to sell assets because it needs to raise US$30 billion of capital.
The combination of US$25 billion of acquisitions in the past 19 months and the lowest cushion for losses ‘in decades’ increases the risk of owning the stock, she said.
Mr Prince, 57, is the third banking chief ousted amid a credit contraction that has saddled the world’s biggest lenders and securities firms with more than US$40 billion of writedowns during the past four months. The worst housing slump in 16 years has led to record US foreclosures and losses in the market for home loans to borrowers with poor credit histories or heavy debts.
Merrill Lynch & Co, the world’s biggest brokerage, ousted Stan O’Neal last week, after the New York-based firm disclosed US$8.4 billion of writedowns. UBS AG, the largest Swiss bank, fired CEO Peter Wuffli in July.
While the writedowns at Citigroup finally brought Mr Prince down, he had been under pressure for years because Citigroup’s performance under his leadership did not match what investors came to expect from Mr Weill, who demanded 15 per cent annual profit increases during his 17 years as CEO of Citigroup, Travelers Group and their predecessors. Powered by a series of blockbuster deals, climaxing with Travelers’ US$36 billion acquisition of Citicorp in 1998, Mr Weill delivered a 160 per cent stock gain during his last five years as CEO.
Mr Prince spent most of his career as Mr Weill’s top lawyer, advising on acquisitions. It was he who untangled Citigroup and Mr Weill from the federal and state probes of analysts who had allegedly talked up stocks to win underwriting business.
Mr Prince’s own stint has been hobbled by the sub-prime crisis. This year, he vowed to eliminate or reassign more than 26,500 jobs. Citigroup’s quarterly profit meanwhile has sunk to its lowest level in three years and the stock has plunged 32 per cent in 2007, twice as much as Bank of America and JPMorgan Chase.
‘I don’t think that all of a sudden, because of the credit crisis, the Citigroup model is broken,’ said Tim Ghriskey, cofounder of Solaris Asset Management in New York. ‘This isn’t a broken machine at all. It just needs some leadership that really understands the business.’
Bloomberg, Reuters, AFP (Business Times 6 Nov 07)